Cancellation: “Hi, Domino’s? Yeah, I’ve changed my mind, keep it.”

6th March 2018

This article first appeared in Legal Futures.

The example in the headline is a facile one, but I’d like to share a few serious(ish) thoughts about cancellation. Most of us have been there; a shiny product and convincing salesperson, and the price never seems expensive when it’s broken down into 80 years’ worth of monthly payments in a finance deal. Then the next day –remorse. But can we cancel? The answer is often yes, but it can turn on some surprisingly arbitrary points.

Let’s talk legislation for a moment. The Consumer Rights Act 2015 brought together the law governing the sale, lease etc. of defective goods to a consumer by a trader. But I want to take a moment to look at the 2015 Act’s less well known cousin, the Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013, which takes aim at those moments just before and during the formation of the contract.

Under the regs, a trader selling goods, services or digital content must provide a range of information to the buyer before and after making a sale. They also give consumers the right to change their minds and cancel, provided the transaction was ‘at a distance’ or ‘off-premises’. This right to cancel is something relatively new to English law which traditionally viewed a contract as being binding once agreed –something to do with ancient notions of honour perhaps – ha! So the regs represented a real shift and left many of us struggling to get our heads around the idea that a consumer can simply change their mind and cancel, quite literally on a whim.

Distance contracts are where the parties are not face-to-face, with the internet being the most obvious example; and the premises referred to in ‘off-premises’ are those of the trader. This part of the 2013 regs is aimed primarily at traders who come to the consumer’s home to try and sell things; double-glazing, and kitchen extensions being common examples; and problems have arisen in respect of the cancellation of these off-premises type of contracts.

The problem for the trader is that they now have to give the consumer notice of their right to cancel, and supply a template cancellation notice. And the regs go further, prescribing that as long as the customer makes a clear statement that they want to cancel, it doesn’t even need to be in writing. Timeframes-wise, the consumer has 14 calendar days in which to cancel, but if the trader fails to follow any of the notice requirements, that period is bumped up to an eye-watering 12 months; all pretty onerous stuff from a trader’s perspective.

However there are some exempted product types for which the notice of cancellation rights do not have to be given. These include ‘investment’ type products, for which the Department of Innovation and Skills –perhaps giving a little too much away about their lifestyle choices –gives the example of ‘vintage wines’. Also exempted are, unsurprisingly, goods which deteriorate rapidly, so sending bananas back after 14-days is a definite no-no, as is returning newspapers and periodicals (even my son can read a newspaper in 14-days, if I push him). But the exemption that has caused the most difficulty is the one for what the regulations describe as being ‘made to the consumer’s specifications or are clearly personalised’.

Most things sold over the internet tend to be very standard, however off-premises contracts are often the opposite, the purpose of a salesperson visiting your home being to try and sell you something specific to that home. As the majority of homes are different, there is an argument that most off-premises contracts will contain an element of the standardised with the personalised and specific. The question is, where to draw the line? When can a set of windows be classed as being to the customer’s exact specification and therefore exempt from the cancellation provision?

The guidance from our vintage wine drinking friends at the Department of Innovation and Skills is that items made to a particular specification are exempt on the basis that a trader might otherwise be left with a product so specific to a particular consumer’s needs that there is no other market for it once the consumer has cancelled the contract. This seems sensible and fair, but it is also narrower than the actual wording of the regs which only require goods to be made to the customer’s specification for them to be exempt from the cancellation provisions.

The challenge with consumer law is that although we often see disputes relating to arguably bespoke goods, very few cases get beyond the courts of first instance and so there is a dearth of judicial guidance on what counts as ‘made to a particular specification’. Until we get something authoritative from the Court of Appeal these ambiguities will remain.

Alastair Greer is Principal Associate at DAS Law.

Alastair Greer

Principal Associate, Solicitor

Learn more

Read more from the DAS Law blog

Goods and services disputes Don’t take a gamble when it comes to online betting

Lewys Traylor gives you the inside track on how to check out the legitimacy of a betting site and your legal options if your online bookie won’t pay you out.

March 2024
Goods and services disputes 4 ways to escape your gym contract in the new year

Gyms are prepared for a New Year’s resolution rush and every January, millions of people rush to sign expensive gym membership contracts. But how fair are these contracts and can you terminate them if your situation changes?

January 2024
Goods and services disputes Your consumer rights when it comes to smart meters

What rights do customers have with smart meter installation and claiming compensation if they have been overcharged?

December 2023
Goods and services disputes What Black Friday and Cyber Monday shoppers should know about their consumer rights

If you are waiting to see the myriad of deals that Black Friday and Cyber Monday will offer, you need to know your rights when it comes to buying online.

November 2023
Protecting your business , Goods and services disputes , Covid-19 What you need to know about hospitality, Covid, and new Health and Safety rules

In light of Covid-19, health and safety rules have changed and venue owners, event organisers and attendees need to be up to speed.

June 2022
Goods and services disputes Online ticket scams are on the rise – here are your legal rights

Do buyers have any legal recourse when it comes to purchasing counterfeit tickets? What are the risks when buying tickets from resellers, and what is the best way to protect yourself from ticket scams?

July 2021
Goods and services disputes An online review could land you in hot water with the law

Could sharing thoughts and experiences online turn into an unexpected legal dispute?

February 2021
Goods and services disputes , Holiday disputes , Professional services disputes , Covid-19 A summary of your consumer rights during the Covid-19 crisis

Whilst we try and navigate the ‘new normal’ there are a number of consumer issues which are causing concern. Simon Roberts looks at everything from shopping to holidays.

June 2020
Goods and services disputes , Covid-19 Online shopping in the time of Covid-19

Thomas Pertaia, Legal Adviser from DAS Law, explains what you need to know about your consumer rights.

May 2020
Goods and services disputes What are your legal rights to a refund if an event is cancelled or postponed due to the coronavirus?

With hundreds of thousands of people affected by the cancellation and/or postponement of events, where does the law stand on refunds for the cost of tickets?

March 2020
Goods and services disputes Can a shop refuse to serve me services based on my gender?

Where does the law stand when it comes to whether or not businesses can refuse a customer based on their gender? Nicole Rogers of DAS Law outlines what you need to know.

February 2020
Employment disputes , Goods and services disputes All you need to know about tipping

Are we legally obliged to tip? Does that money actually go to the staff or is it kept by the business owner? Thomas Pertaia has the answers.

December 2019
Protecting your business , Goods and services disputes What businesses need to know about selling products

By law, any goods that you sell must be as described, of satisfactory quality, and fit for purpose. If the product fails to meet any of these criteria, the buyer is entitled to a refund.

October 2019