The Property Boundaries Bill: Drawing a line under it

9th November 2017

This article first appeared in Legal Futures.

The Property Boundaries (Resolution of Disputes) Bill is currently awaiting its second reading in the House of Lords. So is this the end of the court’s involvement in boundary disputes?

The notes accompanying the Earl of Lytton’s Bill state its admirable intentions as being “…to reduce costs and speed up the process for property boundary disputes.”

The hope is that it will also provide savings in judicial time by removing the majority of boundary disputes from the court process, with the draft Bill also extending to determining the extent of private rights of way in some instances.

If it becomes law all claims currently in the court process for trespass or obstruction of a right of way (where the precise location of the boundary or extent of the private right of way is at issue) will be stayed until the procedures set out in the Bill are followed, with costs implications for those failing to follow the procedures before commencing proceedings.

Well intended and logical, certainly, but will it succeed?

Borrowing heavily from the Party Wall etc. Act 1996, anyone involved in dispute resolution on party wall matters will be familiar with the process and terminology of the new Bill.

In brief, where the owner of land wishes to establish the position of a boundary or extent of a private right of way they must serve notice on the adjoining owner, accompanied by a plan identifying the exact line of the boundary or extent of the right of way.

If the adjoining owner objects within 14 days or does not respond within that period a dispute is deemed to have arisen. If a dispute is deemed to have arisen both parties can appoint a single ‘agreed surveyor’ or each party can appoint their own surveyor, who will in turn select a third surveyor.

The dispute is resolved by an award made by the surveyor or surveyors appointed and they will also determine who pays the cost. Once made, the award is deemed conclusive, although either party has 28 days in which to appeal to the High Court who in turn has the power to rescind or modify the award. Like the Party Wall etc. Act there are no specific grounds of appeal set out.

So is this the end of court involvement in boundary disputes? Well no, the explanatory notes make it clear the Bill does not seek to make expert determination legally conclusive.

There is nothing in there which would give the surveyors any powers to make an award that an adjoining landowner remove anything which is encroaching over the boundary line or obstructing a private right of way, or for that matter for the adjoining land owner to pay compensation if the encroachment were allowed to remain.

Not all boundary disputes are captured by the Bill, with the most notable exclusion being leasehold land, so a leaseholder cannot determine the extent of his title against a freeholder nor can two adjoining leaseholders determine a boundary dispute using the Bill.

Further, a landowner who has a private right of way over another’s land but is not an adjoining owner would also not be able to use the process in the Bill.

Whilst it is entirely laudable to try and remove boundary disputes from the court process, I perceive potential problems with the Bill as currently drafted.

It is clear to see why surveyors are usually considered best placed to resolve a dispute between adjoining owners about how works on a party wall or excavations near neighbouring buildings should be carried out. The questions which need answering though are by their nature surveying questions; the what, how and when works are to be done.

A property dispute is a very distinct creature. For a start, identifying the conveyance or other instrument which first split the two parcels of land in dispute can be difficult or impossible because it often no longer exists.

If the conveyance which split the two parcels of land is available, it needs to be interpreted. Is it the parcel’s clause, plan, both or neither which determines the land conveyed? If extrinsic evidence is to be used, which often it is, what weight needs to be attached to it?

Then there are other areas of law which affect a boundary dispute from adverse possession to proprietary estoppel – none of which a surveyor is equipped to deal with.

There is no doubt that expert determination plays an important role in resolving boundary disputes but it is, at best, only one part of the jigsaw which makes up a boundary dispute. However I am optimistic that this Bill, if enacted, does represent a step in the right direction.

Andrew Jones is a Principal Associate at DAS Law.

Andrew Jones

Principal Associate, Solicitor

Learn more
How to keep your private firework display legal

David Newman sheds light on the laws surrounding Bonfire Night and private firework displays.

October 2020 Learn more
Property boundaries – how disputes can tip neighbours over the edge

When it comes property boundaries and pruning hedges, neighbourly niggles can occur.

May 2020 Learn more

Read more from the DAS Law blog

Property disputes How to keep your private firework display legal

David Newman sheds light on the laws surrounding Bonfire Night and private firework displays.

October 2020
Property disputes 6 things landlords need to know about anti-social behaviour

The government has issued updates to the recent rule changes for repossession in cases of anti-social behaviour / nuisance. Molly-Ellen Turecek tells you what you need to know.

October 2020
Property disputes Struggling to pay your rent? Here’s what you need to know

An estimated 2.6 million tenants are expected to fall behind on rent payments because of the pandemic.

September 2020
Property disputes What landlords need to know about the government’s ‘pre-action protocol’

The courts are due to open again on 23 August. When they do, there will be a new ‘pre-action protocol’ for landlords to comply with.

July 2020
Property disputes Property boundaries – how disputes can tip neighbours over the edge

When it comes property boundaries and pruning hedges, neighbourly niggles can occur.

May 2020
General advice , Property disputes Ho-ho-home invasion: is Father Christmas trespassing?

When he enters your home, is Father Christmas actually trespassing? If he does so without your expressed permission, could he be prosecuted?

December 2019
General advice , Property disputes How far you can legally go to stop people from playing a ‘trick’ on you this Halloween

Halloween is generally a ‘spooktacular’ time for all but a few bad apples can spoil the fun. So what can you do if someone chooses to play a trick and damages your property?

October 2019
Professional services disputes , Property disputes How to take action over low-quality building work

What action can you take when you have a building dispute with a rogue trader? DAS Law’s Bethan Mack takes a look at some important basics.

October 2019
Property disputes Restrictive covenants and where to find them

A restrictive covenant refers to a limitation to what an owner can legally do with their property.

October 2019
Property disputes , Animals Cock-a-doodle…don’t? What the law says about perturbing pets

So where does UK law stand with noisy pets? Damien Field, Legal Adviser at DAS Law explains all.

September 2019
Property disputes , Animals What can you do when a flatmate turns into flat hate?

How to deal with housemate drama? Nicole Rogers, legal adviser at DAS Law, tells prospective flatmates what they need to know.

September 2019
Property disputes What you can do if someone parks outside your home and goes on holiday

Hannah Parsons looks at what you need to know if people are blocking your driveway for weeks on end.

July 2019
Property disputes Things you need to notice about the Tenant Fees Act 2019

The Tenant Fees Act 2019 will bring in controls around the fees paid by tenants in the private rental sector and a cap on tenancy deposits. Keira Brown takes a look at the key changes.

May 2019