Supreme Court Decision on rolled up holiday pay for permanent part year workers

25th July 2022

The long-awaited decision from the Supreme Court (SC) in Harper Trust v Brazel has landed, and sadly it is not good news for those employers who engage workers on permanent part year contracts and had then worked out their holiday pay based on a 12.07% percentage of the hours worked (with the 12.07% being the percentage of 5.6 weeks statutory holiday pay).  However, it is good news for those workers engaged on this basis as they are likely to be owed back pay. 

This decision will likely have a big impact on the education sector, who usually engage staff on permanent term-time only contracts and may have then worked out holiday pay using the 12.07% method.

What does the law say?

Arising from EU law and the Working Time Regulations 1998 (as amended) UK workers are entitled to 5.6 weeks paid holiday per year as a minimum.  The 5.6 weeks is then pro-rated for part time workers who work all year round and have set hours per week.

To work out the average weekly pay for workers who do not have set hours per week, you look back at the last 52 weeks in which a payment has been made (so if there are weeks where no payment is received, you do not include these and look back further), add the payments up and divide the result by 52.  This is the sum you then use to calculate a week’s holiday pay.

What was the practice for those workers who worked part of the year?

The approach employers have taken for a worker who has a permanent contract to work part of the year (and may also have irregular hours when they work) was to pay 12.07% on the hours worked as their holiday pay.  In short, this was a way of pro-rating their holiday pay based on the number of weeks worked each year.  This was initially based on guidance from ACAS, which was rapidly changed after the EAT decision in this case.

What did the Supreme Court decide?

The Supreme Court decided that all workers are entitled to 5.6 weeks annual leave based on their average pay, regardless of how many hours they might work or how many weeks of a year they may work.

This means that whenever a worker takes leave, the employer must work out their holiday pay based on the 52-week method.

What does it mean for you?

If you are a worker who has a permanent part year / irregular hours contract, and your holiday pay has been worked out using the 12.07% method on hours worked, you are likely to be owed back pay and will need to ensure that you are paid the right holiday going forward.

If you are an employer who engages workers on a permanent part year / irregular hours contract, and you have paid that worker holiday worked out using the 12.07% method on hours worked, the worker will have a claim against you for breach of the Working Time Regulations 1998 and unauthorised deduction from wages.

This claim for this back pay could stretch back as far as the date their holiday was paid this way, as there is a question as to whether the legislation that introduced a cap on back pay of 2 years from the date of the claim for unauthorised wages claim will apply to these type of cases.  It is therefore strongly suggested that your business immediately carries out an audit to work out what the historic liability might be and ensure that holiday pay is calculated correctly going forward.

If you need further guidance

If you are a DAS customer, you can get legal advice over the phone as part of your policy; please call the number listed in your policy wording, or request a call here. You may also have access to DAS Businesslaw, our legal documents and guides service.

Learn about DAS Businesslaw

If you do not have legal expenses but would like to request a private consultation with our employment team, please get in touch here.

Disclaimer: This information is for general guidance regarding rights and responsibilities and is not formal legal advice as no lawyer-client relationship has been created. Note that the information was accurate at the time of publication but laws may have since changed.

Public transport strikes – your employment rights if you are unable to get to work

What happens if you can’t make it to work this week due to transport issues? Simon Roberts looks at some key legal facts.

July 2022 Learn more
What employers should do during a heatwave

What are an employer's obligations to employees when the weather gets too hot? Lewys Traylor gives the lowdown.

July 2022 Learn more
What employees need to know about NDAs and confidentiality clauses

What is a Non-Disclosure Agreement? Ryan James from DAS Law takes an in-depth look.

June 2022 Learn more

Read more from the DAS Law blog

Employment disputes Don’t get in trouble with the law on April Fool’s Day

When does the line between hilarious and harsh get crossed and can a prank turn into legal proceedings?

March 2024
Employment disputes Top 10 Settlement Agreement tips for employers

The purpose of a Settlement Agreement is to bring an employment relationship to an end by mutual agreement. Here are our top 10 tips for moving people on with settlement agreements.

March 2024
Employment disputes Do employees get extra pay on a leap year day?

Every four years, many workers find themselves cramming an extra day of work into an already packed year. But are workers in the UK entitled to extra pay for this extra work?

February 2024
Employment disputes How Maternity, Adoption and Shared Parental Leave regulations are changing this year

In this Bitesized Edition, we look at the new Maternity Leave, Adoption Leave and Shared Parental Leave (Amendment) Regulations, set to come into force on 6 April 2024.

February 2024
Employment disputes 9 things employers need to know about apprenticeships

With National Apprenticeship Week here, we explain what employers need to consider regarding apprenticeship schemes and their legal obligations.

February 2024
Employment disputes How flexible working regulations are changing this year

Amendments to the current flexible working legislation will come into force this year. Any flexible working applications made on or after 6 April 2024 must be dealt with in accordance with the regulations.

January 2024
Employment disputes Holiday Pay Guidance from the Government – The Bitesized Edition

The Government has issued guidance on calculating holiday pay to simplify holiday entitlement for irregular hours and part-year workers.

January 2024
General advice , Employment disputes Be on your best behaviour at your work Christmas party

Charlotte Ellis. Legal Adviser at DAS Law, looks at the rules surrounding the office Christmas party.

December 2023
Employment disputes Don’t get a red card while watching the World Cup at work

If you are planning on watching World Cup matches at work there are a number of important things to consider.

August 2023
Employment disputes How employers can prevent harassment or bullying in the workplace

Employers can be liable for employees who have subjected other employees to harassment in the workplace if they have not taken reasonable steps to prevent harassment.

July 2023
Employment disputes How “purpose or reasonable effect” can affect workplace harassment cases

Harassment in the workplace has come under a spotlight in the last few years and employers have put their policies and practices under the spotlight to ensure they are doing all they can to eliminate it.

July 2023
Employment disputes Restrictive covenants in employment contracts – what the government is proposing

employees are departing who may have had access to trade secrets, strategic plans, financial plans and customer or client confidential information.

July 2023
Employment disputes The Sunset Clause Removal: retaining and discarding EU Law – The Bitesized Edition

Following Brexit, in September 2022 the government introduced a bill creating powers to revoke, amend, replace, restate or assimilate approximately 2,400 pieces of EU Law.

June 2023