The Big Gig Rejig – what employers should know about the gig economy

21st March 2019

John GriffithsThis article originally appeared on Legal Futures.

The ‘gig economy’ is never far from the news. DAS Law Solicitor John Griffiths explains where the term comes from, what it means, and how businesses can help themselves today when it comes to clearly defining the status of their people.

For many, the days of CV writing and interviews are gone. Now it is a case of a digital visit to the App Store, with the commute replaced by firing up the chosen app over breakfast. And there are no concerns about making a good impression with a new boss, as algorithms don’t judge your small talk or choice of footwear.

Welcome to the gig economy.

Defined by the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy as “the exchange of labour for money between individuals or companies via digital platforms that actively facilitate matching between providers and customers, on a short-term and payment by task basis” the gig economy is associated with flexibility, convenience, and opportunity – and now employment disputes.

This emerging workforce gained huge momentum through digitisation and in 2018 it was estimated by Wired Magazine that around 1.1 million people in the UK are considered gig economy workers, and this number is predicted to keep rising. And the question of whether this is a resource that is being intelligently utilised or exploited depends of course on your perspective.

Central to this type of work is the already complicated area of employment status. Employee? Worker? Self-employed? Self-employed plus?

No, I didn’t make that last one up, that’s now a thing – more on that below. Whichever of these labels is attached may come with a host of employment rights, or lack thereof, and various other considerations from a legal perspective.

The default position – and this was certainly the perception of employers – was that the gig economy was a group of self-employed people picking up ad hoc work at their discretion, however this came to be disputed as this type of work grew in popularity. But the run of legal challenges on employment status in recent years have highlighted the significant risk that individuals hired as ‘self-employed’, may be actually be considered ‘workers’.

The outcome of cases in this area are highly fact-sensitive, making them unpredictable. That being said, recent trends do show that individuals engaged as self employed contractors in the gig economy are increasingly finding themselves relabelled as workers, gaining rights such as holiday pay, sick pay and minimum wage.

Case law background

Since 2012 there has been a steady stream of cases on this subject making their way through our legal system.

OK, more accurately for a long time it was the same case heard at ascending levels, with the Supreme Court eventually in June 2018 upholding a decision that an engineer at Pimlico Plumbers should be deemed a worker. And in other high profile decisions in recent years, cases involving a CitySprint cycle courier, an Addison Lee driver, and Uber drivers were all decided similarly – these were ‘workers’.

Was the Gig up? Not entirely. Contrary to this trend, in November 2017, the Central Arbitration Committee (CAC) decided that Deliveroo cyclists were ‘self-employed’. This has since taken been taken to the High Court, where the decision was upheld.

The crux of this decision lay with contractual substitution provisions. The courts are aware of the fact that some contractual substitution provisions are shams designed to avoid granting entitlements. In this case however, evidence was shown that riders could (and did) give out their password details enabling substitutes to provide the service on their behalf.

How have employers reacted?

One significant player in this space has adopted a creative approach to providing some clarity by creating a new class of arrangement, dubbed the ‘self-employed plus’. Courier company Hermes devised the new classification following a deal with the GMB Union, who won a case against Hermes in the Employment Tribunal in June 2018.

The outcome was that the ‘lifestyle couriers’ (couriers who deliver on a flexible schedule using their own vehicles) were to be deemed ‘workers’.

Under this new status, an individual can opt in and gain the benefit of paid holiday and fixed pay rates, and full GMB Union representation. In exchange for this security, new couriers must follow Hermes’ pre-prescribed delivery routes.

But individuals also have option to opt out, and to continue to earn a premium rate for certain jobs but forgo basic workers’ rights, such as the national minimum wage, holiday and sick pay.

What your business could do

There are certainly steps employers can take to help indicate that the status of a person carrying out work for them is that of ‘self-employed’. I’d suggest that these include:

  • Make it clear there is no obligation to perform the work personally. If possible, include an unfettered right of substitution.
  • Avoid restrictions on the individual’s ability to provide services i.e. when, how and where they provide services.
  • Avoid fixed hours of work and fixed weekly or monthly retainer fees.
  • Avoid the provision of holiday pay, sick pay or other employment benefits.
  • Avoid steps that integrate the individual within the business.
  • Avoid the use of branded uniforms and equipment.
  • Allow and encourage the individual to carry out work for others.
  • Ensure individuals bear their own expenses and equipment.
  • Evidencing the parties’ intention to create a contract for the provision of services and not a contract of employment from the outset.

Keep these factors in mind when assessing your workforce/relationship with your client or employer and it will put you in good stead when making an educated assessment of the scenario.

Disclaimer: This information is for general guidance regarding rights and responsibilities and is not formal legal advice as no lawyer-client relationship has been created.

How to navigate employment rights in the gig economy

If you are unsure about your employment status, the rights and benefits that come with it, you need advice from professionals who understand the law.

July 2018 Learn more
How to avoid workplace discrimination in your business

Businesses must do all they can to prevent discrimination in the workplace and being up-to-date with equality law is essential.

April 2018 Learn more
9 questions and answers about the gig economy

We talked about the basics of the gig economy with Allison Lewis, Head of Employment at DAS Law.

February 2018 Learn more

Read more from the DAS Law blog

Employment disputes How to deal with mental health discrimination at work

There are legal protections in place to support those with a mental health condition. Here’s what you need to know if you are being treated unfairly at work because of your mental health.

October 2019
Employment disputes Don’t get a red card while watching the World Cup at work

If you are planning on watching World Cup matches at work there are a number of important things to consider.

September 2019
Employment disputes Can your boss force you to work the August Bank Holiday?

Can you refuse to work on a bank holiday? DAS Law’s Hannah Parsons outlines your rights.

August 2019
Employment disputes , Goods and services disputes , Professional services disputes Is the customer always right when it comes to alcohol and pregnancy?

A recent Reddit post sparked debate on personal accountability and the rights of serving staff when it comes to alcohol. Larna Mason explains what the law says.

August 2019
Employment disputes What employers should do during a heatwave

What are an employer's obligations to employees when the weather gets too hot? Hannah Parsons gives the lowdown.

July 2019
Employment disputes , Protecting your business How working time regulations can limit your employees’ hours

A study by French researchers has highlighted some of the health risks faced by those working long hours. Sarah Garner, Solicitor at DAS Law, looks at the specific rules and regulations regarding the working day.

July 2019
Employment disputes When should a condition be classified as a disability?

DAS Law Senior Associate and Legal Executive Tessa Faverty considers this crucial question, drawing on her professional expertise, and personal experience.

June 2019
Employment disputes Can an employer ban working from home?

A recent ban on working from home at BNY Mellon raised questions about what an employee’s rights are when it comes to working from home.

June 2019
Employment disputes Scope of ‘injury to feelings’ expanded by employment tribunal

In employment law, awards for ‘injury to feelings’ have historically been permitted only in claims linked to discrimination, whistleblowing, and trade union membership, but the situation may now have changed.

May 2019
Employment disputes , Protecting your business When can company directors be personally liable?

The recent High Court case of Antzuzis & Others v DJ Houghton Catching Services & Others is a stark reminder of how company directors can be personally liable for their acts.

May 2019
Employment disputes 10 employment law changes to look out for

Hayley Marles highlights ten changes that HR professionals & business owners need to be aware of, including Brexit immigration rule changes.

April 2019
Employment disputes , Protecting your business 6 tips for giving your business a “spring clean”

Are your staff handbooks up-to-date? Are your staff taking all of their holiday allowance? Give your business a spring clean with these six tips for a clean and tidy SME.

April 2019
Employment disputes Don’t get in trouble with the law on April Fool’s Day

When does the line between hilarious and harsh get crossed and can a prank turn into legal proceedings?

March 2019