HMRC wins ‘freelance’ case against TV host Eamon Holmes – What does this mean for the rest of us?

The recent court case involving ’This Morning’ host Eamon Holmes and HMRC over his remuneration has highlighted the issue of how workers are categorised.

9th March 2020

The TV presenter claimed that he is a freelancer, meaning he is paid through his own company, however HMRC had a different view and the case went to court where the ruling went in favour of HMRC.

How can people stay on the right side of the law when it comes to their employment status and tax? Nicole Rogers from DAS Law has the answers.

Do you think the recent Eamon Holmes case opens the floodgates when it comes to these kinds of cases, and HMRC pursuing individuals?

Possibly; private sector individuals are coming under more scrutiny and Eamon Holmes is one of a few TV personalities to have lost at the First Tier Tribunal. However, whilst not directly relating to IR35, the floodgates seem to have been open for some time as the courts have shown willingness to determine status as an employee or worker in other recent high profile cases.

What are the rules governing whether a person is considered freelance or employed?

 This has been a topical subject and has attracted much attention recently. Employment status is generally split between employee, worker and self-employed, with the latter usually subject to different rules for tax and NI.

By way of background, the status of an individual is a question for the Employment Tribunal but generally, the following components are typical for each category;

Employees

  • Mutuality of obligation – must provide work and must accept work
  • Employer pays tax and NI
  • Employer exercises control over how employee works
  • Cannot supply a substitute
  • Uses employer equipment

Workers

  • No mutuality of obligation
  • Arrangement is casual
  • Some degree of control
  • Cannot supply a substitute
  • Employer pays tax and NI
  • Uses employer equipment

Self-employed

  • No mutuality of obligation
  • May work autonomously – minimal degree of control
  • Uses own equipment
  • Pays own tax
  • Can supply a substitute

The IR35 legislation was introduced as it was perceived that individuals could engage in particular forms of tax avoidance. Individuals were able to supply their services through an intermediary, usually their own personal company, resulting in them being able to circumvent the obligations to pay employee income tax and National Insurance contributions.

The IR35 rules seek to ensure that individuals, who would otherwise be regarded as employees had they been providing their services directly, are broadly subject to the same tax and National Insurance obligations as regular employees.

What can employers/employees do to make sure they stay on the right side of the law?

Taking legal advice and following HMRC guidance is a sensible step as the IR35 rules are complex and are often challenged. Generally, the status of an individual and the components displayed above will be of significant importance; merely labelling a person as ‘self-employed’ will be subject to great scrutiny if the day-to-day treatment is similar to that of an employee.

Having said that, whilst the practical reality of an engagement is paramount, the written contracts will also be relevant. It is likely that two contracts will be present; one between the employer and the intermediary company and one between the intermediary company and the individual. Both contracts should be professionally drafted, but it is arguable that the former will be of most importance. This is because the contract would need to bear the hallmarks of a self-employed arrangement.

It is highly advisable for employers to take legal advice on the changes relating to IR35 due in April 2020.

Disclaimer: This information is for general guidance regarding rights and responsibilities and is not formal legal advice as no lawyer-client relationship has been created. Note that the information was accurate at the time of publication but laws may have since changed.

5 things you need to know about missing the self-assessment tax return deadline

With 31 January deadline fast approaching, time is ticking for the UK’s 5.4m tax payers to submit their Self-Assessment tax returns.

January 2024 Learn more
How to navigate employment rights in the gig economy

If you are unsure about your employment status, the rights and benefits that come with it, you need advice from professionals who understand the law.

July 2018 Learn more

Read more from the DAS Law blog

Employment disputes Sexual Harassment in the Workplace – A Time for Change

Here’s how things are changing for employers in respect of their duties regarding the prevention of sexual harassment in the workplace as of 26 October 2024.

September 2024
Employment disputes Workplace mediation – a better alternative?

At some point an employer will need to deal with workplace conflict. Workplace mediation can help to foster positive working relationships.

July 2024
Employment disputes 10 top TUPE tips for employers – Transferees

TUPE kicks in when there is a transfer of a business from one organisation to another or there is a service provision change from one provider to another.

June 2024
Employment disputes Faulty products face recalls – these are your rights when things go wrong

Gurkaran Singh Gill looks at what you can do if you have bought a faulty product.

May 2024
Employment disputes 10 top TUPE tips for employers – Transferors

Here are our top 10 TUPE tips for the Transferor – this is usually the seller of the business to another or a client seeking to outsource a service.

May 2024
Employment disputes What employers need to know about performance management and grievances

Thomas Eastment, Legal Adviser at DAS, looks at how employers can balance performance management while ensuring fair and legally compliant grievance resolution.

May 2024
Employment disputes Managing absence – an employer’s perspective

Employers must navigate the delicate balance between supporting staff welfare and ensuring operational efficiency.

April 2024
Employment disputes Employee, self-employed or worker? – The Bitesized Edition

Employment status can be complex if an organisation does not define the relationship with an individual clearly and reflective of the actual relationship in practice.

April 2024
Employment disputes Workplace stress: your responsibilities as an employer

Commenting on Stress Awareness Week, Sarah Garner, Solicitor at DAS Law, takes a look at what the law says employers needs to do about stress.

April 2024
Employment disputes International Stress Awareness Month: your workplace rights

To mark International Stress Awareness Month, Sarah Garner takes a look at what the law says your employer needs to do about workplace stress.

April 2024
Employment disputes Don’t get in trouble with the law on April Fool’s Day

When does the line between hilarious and harsh get crossed and can a prank turn into legal proceedings?

March 2024
Employment disputes Top 10 Settlement Agreement tips for employers

The purpose of a Settlement Agreement is to bring an employment relationship to an end by mutual agreement. Here are our top 10 tips for moving people on with settlement agreements.

March 2024
Employment disputes Do employees get extra pay on a leap year day?

Every four years, many workers find themselves cramming an extra day of work into an already packed year. But are workers in the UK entitled to extra pay for this extra work?

February 2024