Constructive & wrongful dismissal

If you feel forced to resign, this may count as constructive dismissal. If you are dismissed in breach of the terms of your employment contract, this is known as wrongful dismissal.

26th April 2018

Dismissals

Several issues can arise in situations where work comes to an end. Constructive dismissal is one of them - this is where you feel forced to quit your job due to your work conditions becoming intolerable. Another is wrongful dismissal, where you are dismissed in breach of the terms of your contract - for example, when you are not given the notice period you are entitled to.

It's important to note that neither of these issues constitute unfair dismissal in themselves, but they may open the way for you to make a claim for unfair dismissal.

Constructive dismissal

Constructive dismissal is the term used for when you resign from your job due to your employer’s conduct or due to actions that make you feel as though you are being ‘forced out’. Even though it seems as though this is not dismissal because you chose to resign, if your employer treats you so badly at work that they make you feel as though you need to leave, this counts as them breaching their contract with you and therefore amounts to a dismissal.

if your employer treats you so badly that they make you feel that have to leave, this counts as them breaching your contract

The conduct of your employer must, however, be seriously unacceptable before you can consider yourself to have been constructively dismissed. It may be that their actions build up over time to make your job intolerable, or it could be that one extremely severe incident leads you to resign.

Some ways in which an employer could force you into a constructive dismissal may include:

  • a failure to pay your wages or to pay them on time
  • changing your working conditions without asking you; for example, telling you to work in another location which is difficult for you to get to
  • harassing or insulting you at work

You will usually be expected to initially try and sort out the problem with your employer, rather than immediately resigning. As a result, your employer is required to provide information on their procedures for raising a grievance.

However, if the grievance procedure fails to help, you may then reach a point where you feel you have no choice but to resign. If this is the case, you should do so as soon as possible, as it may be hard to prove that your working conditions were unacceptable if you tolerated them for a long time. If you try to bring a claim afterwards, your employer may argue that you had effectively accepted what was happening.

It is important to note that having been constructively dismissed does not necessarily mean that you were unfairly dismissed; it only shows that your resignation counts as a dismissal. You will have to prove separately that the reason for your dismissal was unfair – see the unfair dismissal section above.

If you feel that you have been unfairly or constructively dismissed, there are a number of steps you can take to resolve the issue. Take a look at our problems at work blog to find out what you will need to do.

Wrongful dismissal

If your employer dismisses you in a way which breaches the terms of your contract, this is what is known as ‘wrongful dismissal’.

Wrongful dismissal cases usually arise when an employer either fails to give you sufficient notice as set out in your contract, or does not follow the appropriate procedures that they have laid down for dismissal situations.

wrongful dismissal cases arise when an employer either fails to give sufficient notice, or does not follow procedures

  1. Statutory notice periods

If your notice period is not stated in your contract, then you have a fall back in the form of your statutory employment rights. You should be given one week’s notice after being employed for one month. After this, every year you have worked will add another month to this minimum notice period, up to a maximum of twelve weeks’ notice.

If your contract promises you a longer notice period than this, you are of course entitled to that amount of notice, but you should always receive the statutory minimum notice period if nothing else has been specified.

If you are not legally entitled to a specific minimal notice period – if you have been employed for less than a month, for example - your employment rights still state that you should get a “reasonable” notice period. This is of course open to interpretation, but your employer will need to demonstrate that they acted reasonably if challenged on it. This may be based on how often you get paid – for example, you may be able to argue that a month’s notice period is reasonable if you are paid once a month.

  1. Compensation amounts and other grounds for claiming

The award you can expect for a wrongful dismissal claim is likely to amount to what you would have earned had you been allowed to work through your notice period, as you should have been permitted to under the terms of your contract.

It is not just the notice period that can lead to a claim of wrongful dismissal. Your employer will also be required to follow certain procedures if they want to dismiss you, so a failure to do so means that they could find themselves in hot water. Essentially, any breach of contract performed when dismissing an employee can give rise to a wrongful dismissal claim.

  1. Who can claim for wrongful dismissal?

Because a wrongful dismissal claim involves breach of contract, there is no minimum time period for which you must have worked in order to make one. In breaching the contract, your employer has broken the law. For this reason, while an employment tribunal can hear a wrongful dismissal claim which does not exceed £25,000 in value, they could also go before a county court or high court.

In breaching the contract, your employer has broken the law.

Counterintuitively, wrongful dismissal does not actually necessarily mean that they had no good reason to dismiss you or would not have been permitted to, but merely that the way in which they carried out your dismissal was incorrect.

Dismissal from work

In the majority of cases, if your employer wants to dismiss you from your job, they are required by law to follow certain procedures to ensure that everything is done fairly. Make sure you know your employment rights in a dismissal situation.

April 2018 Learn more
Disciplinary action

Your employer may take formal disciplinary action against you if they are unhappy with any aspect of your behaviour in the workplace. However they must follow a fair procedure when doing so.

April 2018 Learn more
Find an employment tribunal

When you need to take your employer or ex-employer to task, employment tribunals are a force to be reckoned with. Here’s how to find your nearest tribunal office.

April 2018 Learn more

Read more from the DAS Law blog

Employment disputes Working on Christmas Day – your rights if you end up on the rota

It's a day of rest for millions, but for others it’s double the workload as business continues as normal – but with fewer staff. Can you refuse? Hannah Parsons outlines your rights.

December 2018
General advice , Employment disputes The dos and don’ts of the office Christmas party

Hannah Parsons, solicitor at DAS Law, has the following advice to ensure that your office party does not result in writs and recriminations.

December 2018
Employment disputes International Stress Awareness Day: your workplace rights

For this Wednesday’s International Stress Awareness Day, Hannah Parsons, a solicitor at DAS Law, takes a look at what the law says your employer needs to do about stress.

November 2018
Employment disputes Your rights if it’s too cold in the workplace

As the winter weather arrives with a vengeance, chilly workplaces across the UK are potentially having serious impacts on the health and effectiveness of employees.

October 2018
Employment disputes How to deal with mental health discrimination at work

There are legal protections in place to support those with a mental health condition. Here’s what you need to know if you are being treated unfairly at work because of your mental health.

October 2018
Employment disputes How to navigate employment rights in the gig economy

If you are unsure about your employment status, the rights and benefits that come with it, you need advice from professionals who understand the law.

July 2018
Employment disputes Don’t get a red card while watching the World Cup at work

If you are planning on watching World Cup matches at work there are a number of important things to consider.

July 2018
Employment disputes Winter commuting: I thawed the law

If you run your own business, bad weather can cause chaos when staff can’t get in. What employment law regulations are in place when handling transport troubles in winter?

February 2018
Employment disputes 9 questions and answers about the gig economy

We talked about the basics of the gig economy with Allison Whiston, Head of Employment and Commercial at DAS Law.

February 2018
Employment disputes Suspension: a neutral act?

A decision in a recent case determined that suspension was not a ‘neutral act’ and can amount to a breach of trust and confidence.

January 2018
Employment disputes Constructive & wrongful dismissal

If you feel forced to resign, this may count as constructive dismissal. If you are dismissed in breach of the terms of your employment contract, this is known as wrongful dismissal.

April 2018
Employment disputes , Protecting your business Managing stress in the workplace

For National Stress Awareness Day (Wednesday 1st November), we take a look at what the law says your employer needs to do about stress

October 2017
Employment disputes Disciplinary action

Your employer may take formal disciplinary action against you if they are unhappy with any aspect of your behaviour in the workplace. However they must follow a fair procedure when doing so.

April 2018